Why Do Some Busy Cafés Still Struggle to Make a Profit?

Why Do Some Busy Cafés Still Struggle to Make a Profit?

Full tables don't always mean loads of profit. We see it all the time: venues absolutely slammed from open to close, wondering why the bank account doesn't match the vibe.

Don't get us wrong - It's rarely about laziness or bad intentions. It's about tiny profit leaks happening in real-time while everyone's head-down busy.

Let's jump into some of the main causes at a high level.

‍

Margins quietly drift over time

Most venues price their menu once, then "life happens" and no one circles back.

Ingredient costs go up. Portions get a bit more "generous". Supplier invoices creep higher. And suddenly, that dish that used to make you $8 is barely clearing $4.

And the kicker? It's usually your bestsellers getting hit hardest.

You can be flat-out all day, selling hundreds of items that feel profitable but actually aren't anymore. Being busy doesn't help if you're working with yesterday's numbers. Keep in the know - set a rhythm to review your gross profit, and start with your bestsellers.

If you can’t see your numbers clearly, that’s the real problem.

Flat out is fine, but profitable is better.

Key Action: Set aside 3hrs on one day every month to review your costs and gross profit. Always best to start with your bestsellers.

High volume is not the same as high profit

When something's popular, it's tempting to lean into it harder. Makes sense, right?

Except those crowd-pleasers can often:

• Take longer to make
• Need more hands-on deck
• Leave less margin than you think

Volume's great at hiding problems. You can sell a mountain of something and still not actually make much per sale. Regularly review your gross profit per item. Check prep time. Check labour. Check margin.

If you don’t know what each sale leaves behind, you’re guessing.

High volume is fine but high margin is better.

Key Action: Step back from 'doing' and watch how your team makes and delivers a top seller - from taking the order to delivering the plate. Watch for inefficiencies, ingredient usage and team morale.

‍

Labour costs blow out when your flow's not right

Labour's one of your biggest costs, but throwing fewer people at it isn't always the answer.

The real problem? Friction.

Orders taking way too long. Payment taking forever. Staff pinned to one station when they could be helping elsewhere.

It's not about cutting warmth or service quality - it's about removing the bottlenecks that slow everyone down. When flow improves, your team naturally works better and customers have a smoother time.

Fix the bottlenecks. Improve the flow. And choose hospitality POS and online ordering systems that support your team instead of replacing them.

Great hospitality runs smoother when systems handle the admin - and people handle the magic.

Key Action: Watch how long it takes for your team to process an order and move through the queue/section. If their heads spend more time looking at the till than the customer - you have an issue.

‍Big menus quietly drain you

A huge menu feels impressive. But it costs you in ways that don't show up on the POS. More stock to wrangle. More waste. Slower service. Training that takes twice as long.

And then there are those items that sell once a week but complicate every single shift. They're expensive passengers. Use your POS reports to review your menu regularly. Cut what doesn’t sell. Simplify what slows the kitchen. Protect your best-margin, best-moving items.Impressive isn’t the goal -  sustainable is.

Key Action - Every month report on your top 10 non-movers and make a call to delete or re-envigorate.

‍

Waste happens in tiny, repetitive ways

Profit loss usually isn't one dramatic mistake. It's a hundred small ones stacking up:

• Prepping too much
• Eyeballing portions
• Remaking orders
• Keeping things available past their prime

Most cafés and restaurants don't lose money in big chunks. They lose it in small amounts, many times a day, while everyone's too busy to notice.

The truth is, busy venues don't struggle because people aren't working hard. They struggle because profit quietly leaks out while everyone's in the weeds.

The fix? Clarity. On your margins, your flow, your menu, your waste. Clarity turns motion into actual money.

Key Action - Ask your team for feedback on what causes them the most friction every 2 months. Act on the top culprit.

‍

How we think about this at Bustle

Bustle's built by hospitality people who obsess over things like flow, clarity, and keeping the human side of service intact. If any of what you've read here hit home and you want to talk it through, we're always up for a chat.